Skip to content

Applicants

Questions to Ask Before You Buy an Expert Letter for Your Petition

Some companies sell expert opinion letters for EB-1A, EB-2 NIW and O-1 petitions. Before you pay, ask who writes the letter, how the expert knows your work, and what happens if USCIS issues an RFE. Here is a checklist.

Questions to ask before you buy an expert letter. Meritocrat

Searching for "expert opinion letter" for an EB-1A, EB-2 NIW or O-1 petition brings up many companies that offer to arrange one. Some are careful. Some sell the same letter again and again. The price tells you little, so the questions you ask matter more.

This checklist covers what to ask before you pay. It is not an endorsement of any company, and it is meant to help whichever one you consider.

This is general information, not legal advice. Check your own facts with an immigration attorney.

First, know what a letter can and cannot do

The USCIS Policy Manual says letters should not form the cornerstone of an extraordinary ability claim. Statements in them should be backed by documents, and letters that only repeat USCIS's definitions are generally not persuasive. Our guide to what makes an expert letter strong covers what officers look for.

So a letter helps when it adds specific, documented information about your work, and not just praise.

The checklist

1. Who writes the draft? Ask whether the expert writes the letter, or whether the company prepares a draft for the expert to sign. If there is a draft, ask what the expert changes and how.

2. Does the expert write in their own words? Letters that share wording across a petition can raise questions. A law firm's review of RFE patterns notes that identical language across letters can call independence into question. Ask whether letters come from templates.

3. How does the expert know your work? A strong letter explains the basis of the writer's knowledge. Ask what the expert will review, such as your papers, citations or documents, and whether they will describe what they actually read.

4. Is the expert truly independent? Ask how the company checks that the expert has no prior connection to you or your employer, and whether the expert confirms that in writing.

5. Can you approve the expert first? Ask whether you and your attorney can review the expert's CV before you pay, and say no if the person is not right for your field.

6. Can you see a sample? Ask for a sample letter with the applicant's details removed. Look for specifics, not just general praise. Ask whether other letters look the same.

7. How many edits are included? Find out how many rounds of changes you get, and whether further edits cost extra.

8. What happens if you get an RFE? Ask whether the company will revise the letter or supply another expert if USCIS issues an RFE that mentions it, and what that costs.

9. What are the refund terms? Read them before you pay, including what happens if the expert cannot complete the letter.

10. How do they handle your documents? You will send your CV and evidence. Ask how they store it and who sees it.

Red flags

  • A promise that a letter will get you approved. No letter can promise that, and neither can anyone else.
  • A price much lower than others, with no explanation.
  • Refusal to show a sample or to name how experts are chosen.
  • Pressure to pay before you have seen the expert's CV.
  • Advice to skip your attorney.

O-1 petitions have an extra requirement

O-1 petitions generally need a separate written consultation from a relevant peer group, labor organization or management organization. A letter from a vendor's expert does not replace it. Your attorney can tell you what applies to your case.

Before you decide

  1. Talk to your attorney about whether an expert letter fits your case and which expert to accept.
  2. Map the letter to a criterion so you know what it must show.
  3. Check your evidence first. A free EB-1A assessment shows where your evidence is strong, thin or missing, so you do not pay for a letter that doesn't address a real gap. There is also an EB-2 NIW assessment and an O-1 assessment.

Need an expert letter?

Disclosure: Meritocrat is a referral partner of International Association of Experts (IAE), an independent company. If you buy through the links below, IAE pays Meritocrat a referral fee. It does not change your price.

Ask your attorney whether a letter fits your case before you buy, and confirm IAE's price and process with IAE directly. Our partner page has more.

Sources

Meritocrat is not a law firm and this is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to buy an expert letter?
Paying for a service that helps you obtain an expert opinion is not by itself unlawful. What matters is that the letter is truthful, that the expert actually holds the opinion, and that nothing about it is misleading. Ask your attorney whether a particular service and approach fit your case.
Will USCIS know a letter was bought?
Officers judge a letter on what it says, who wrote it, how the writer knows your work, and whether documents support it. A letter that is generic or sounds like other letters in the same petition may be given less weight, whoever arranged it.
Who should write the draft?
Many practitioners suggest that writers describe your work in their own words, based on your facts and documents. If a company prepares a draft, ask how the expert reviews and changes it, and whether the final letter reflects the expert's own knowledge. Ask your attorney before you decide.
Does an expert letter replace the O-1 advisory opinion?
No. An O-1 petition generally requires a separate written consultation from a relevant peer group, labor organization or management organization. An expert letter from a vendor does not take the place of it. Your attorney can explain what applies to your case.
What if I get an RFE after buying a letter?
Talk to your attorney right away. Ask the company in advance what it does in that case, such as revising the letter or supplying another expert, and whether that costs extra.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Meritocrat is a preparation tool, not a law firm, and does not replace qualified legal counsel.

Prepare your case in one connected workspace

Case Studio helps EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, and O-1 applicants organize evidence and review what supports each claim.

Start Your CaseWatch the Demo

Browse all 144 articles →