Applicants
Why USCIS Gives Support Letters Less Weight (and How to Avoid It)
An RFE that says your letters are not independent, or are conclusory, is common in EB-1A and NIW cases. Here are the usual reasons officers discount letters and what you can do before you file.

If you have read RFEs for EB-1A or EB-2 NIW petitions, you have seen it: "The letters are not independent," or "The letters make general claims without specifics." It is one of the most repeated objections, and in many cases it can be avoided before you file.
This guide explains the usual reasons officers give letters less weight, and how to check your own before filing.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check your own facts with an immigration attorney.
What the Policy Manual says
The USCIS Policy Manual's guidance on extraordinary ability petitions says letters should not form the cornerstone of a claim, that the statements in them should be corroborated by documents, and that letters merely reiterating USCIS's definitions are generally not persuasive. It also says officers look for acclaim extending well beyond the circle of the person's personal and professional acquaintances.
Those few lines explain most RFEs about letters.
The usual reasons letters are discounted
According to a law firm's review of RFE language, officers raise these points most often.
1. The writer is too close to you. Letters from a current or former employer, supervisor or close collaborator are often treated as less independent. A detailed letter backed by documents from such a writer can still be weighed, but it will not show acclaim from outside your circle.
2. The letter is conclusory. It says you are exceptional without saying what you did, why it mattered, or how it changed the field.
3. It discusses the field, not you. A letter that explains why your field is important, without describing your own contributions, adds little.
4. No basis of knowledge. The writer does not say how they know what they claim, for example through your publications or by using your work.
5. It is not proof. Submitting letters does not by itself establish that you meet a criterion. Officers weigh them for relevance, reliability and support from your documents.
6. Letters that sound alike. The same law firm notes that identical language across letters, or notably similar wording and structure, can raise questions about whether the writers prepared them independently. The firm cites an adopted AAO decision, Matter of R-K-K-, on this point. Whether that applies in your case is a question for your attorney.
How to avoid it
- Map each letter to a criterion or prong. Before you ask anyone to write, know what the letter will show.
- Use a mix of writers. Independent experts for significance. Collaborators for facts only they know. Employers where the criterion calls for them.
- Have writers say how they know your work. A short statement of their expertise and their basis of knowledge.
- Ask for specifics. Dates, numbers, projects and outcomes, in plain language.
- Give writers your facts, then let them write. Share your CV and key documents so the letter is accurate, and let each person use their own words. If the letters share the same phrasing, they will read as one voice.
- Match every claim to a document. If a letter says your method was adopted by others, your exhibits should show it.
- Read the set together. Look for repeated stories, repeated phrases and gaps.
- Have your attorney review the set before filing.
If you already have an RFE
Talk to your attorney right away. Typical responses add new independent letters that explain how the writers know your work, and add documents that support the claims. Our guide on EB-1A criteria and what evidence counts can help you check each criterion, and the post on moving from random evidence to structured evidence shows a way to organize your record.
If you are still preparing, a free EB-1A assessment shows where your evidence is strong, thin or missing, and there is an EB-2 NIW assessment too.
Need an expert letter?
Disclosure: Meritocrat is a referral partner of International Association of Experts (IAE), an independent company. If you buy through the links below, IAE pays Meritocrat a referral fee. It does not change your price.
- Expert opinion letters for EB-1A, EB-2 NIW and O-1 (IAE)
- Expert letters for RFE and NOID responses (IAE)
Ask your attorney whether a letter fits your case before you buy, and confirm IAE's price and process with IAE directly. Our partner page has more.
Sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2: Extraordinary Ability
- Locke Immigration, Your Support Letters Are Not Independent (RFE encyclopedia)
- F1Jobs, Independent Expert Letters vs. Collaborator Letters in EB-1A and NIW Cases
Meritocrat is not a law firm and this is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
- What does it mean when USCIS says my letters are not independent?
- It means the officer thinks the writers are too closely tied to you or your employer to show acclaim from outside your circle. Letters from employers, supervisors or close collaborators are often given less weight for this reason, although a detailed, well-supported letter from such a writer can still count.
- Why would USCIS call a letter conclusory?
- A conclusory letter makes broad statements, such as that you are among the best in your field, without explaining what you did, why it mattered or how the writer knows. These letters add little beyond your documents.
- Can letters that sound alike hurt my case?
- A law firm's review of USCIS RFE patterns says that identical wording across letters can call into question whether the writers prepared them independently. Letters that each describe different facts in the writer's own words avoid this.
- Does one weak letter sink the petition?
- Not by itself. Officers weigh the whole record. But a set made up mostly of weak or similar letters gives you less to rely on at the final merits review.
- What can I do if I get an RFE about my letters?
- Talk to your attorney right away. Common responses are adding independent letters that explain how the writers know your work, and adding documents that back up the claims the letters make.
Prepare your case in one connected workspace
Case Studio helps EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, and O-1 applicants organize evidence and review what supports each claim.